By Editorial Staff
In the game Monopoly®, one of the best cards you
can draw from the Community Chest pile begins with the phrase “Bank error in
your favor.” One of the worst cards in the game orders a player to proceed
directly to jail. This month’s Sphincter inanely managed to combine the two,
and as a result, a man faces 25 years in prison.
Benjamin Lovell, a 48-year-old salesman from Brownsfield,
New York, is charged with first-degree grand larceny for withdrawing over $2
million from Commerce Bank after employees convinced him that it was his money
when, in fact, they had confused him with another Benjamin Lovell.
On December 14, Lovell was making a $400 deposit when he was
informed by a teller that he had $5.8 million in another account. Much to his
credit, a befuddled Lovell, who earns $600 a week working for KeySpan, spoke to
the manager and other bank officials about his unexpected windfall. They all
reportedly insisted that the money was his and there was no problem with him
withdrawing as much as he wished.
Presumably thinking that miracles do happen, Lovell
immediately withdrew $10,000. Later that day, he took out another $990,000, and
over the next four weeks, he allegedly withdrew another $1.1 million. In the
interim, no one at the bank had a clue they had inexcusably mixed up the Social
Security Numbers of this poor schmuck and a Philadelphia shoe mogul.
Earlier in December, the monetary mayhem was set into motion
when Woodlawn Trustee, the rightful owner of the larger account, asked the bank
to authorize the second, more affluent Lovell to act on their account.
Unfortunately for the first, less prosperous Lovell, the idiots at Commerce
Bank indefensibly turned this simple, routine, administrative task into a
felonious, $6-million tease.
It took the wunderkinds at “America’s Most Convenient Bank”
two months to figure out their colossal screwup, but Lovell was eventually
arrested on February 18. At his arraignment the next day in Brooklyn Criminal
Court, it was ordered that Lovell be held in lieu of $3 million bond or $1
million cash bail.
Why he was given such an exorbitant bond is beyond us. After
all, he only took $2 million. At least he had the decency to leave the rest for
the rightful owner.
Furthermore, after the married dad gave $36,000 to his
friends and spent $8,000 on jewelry for his girlfriend, he tried to be a good
steward of his illegally acquired money by investing $1.5 million in the stock
market. Unfortunately for Lovell, his brief stint as a member of the nouveau
riche coincided with a bear market. His investments went bad and he couldn’t
pay back the money. Only $500,000 was recovered.
We’re not saying that Lovell should get off scot-free, but
Commerce Bank should bear some of the responsibility. If not for their colossal
f–k up, none of this would have happened. Besides, how could authorities
reasonably expect an underpaid salesman with a mistress and $800 in his bank
account to resist such a temptation, especially when it’s virtually thrust upon
him by a bunch of semi-retarded bank officials?
Some people have their lives turned around when Oprah gives
them an assload of money. This guy probably just thought the bank was his
mystical Harpo Productions.
Click here to discuss this article on our Message Board. This article was originally posted on
March 07, 2008